Dexter: Resurrection’s ‘Too Tidy’ ending spells trouble for Season 2

Dexter: Resurrection wrapped its explosive first season with a finale that tied up almost every loose end, perhaps a little too neatly.

While fans enjoyed a satisfying conclusion, the polished finish may leave Paramount+ in a difficult position if the hit series fails to return.

Creator Clyde Phillips has been clear about his ambition for a multi-season story, but the streamer has yet to confirm a second run.

That uncertainty has only deepened since Paramount+ abruptly cancelled the prequel, Dexter: Original Sin, despite reports it had been renewed.

Notably, Episode 10, And Justice For All…, saw Dexter eliminate Leon Prater (Peter Dinklage), frame him for Angel Batista’s tragic death, and bring the New York Ripper case to a close.

With the “serial killer club” dismantled, Harrison (Jack Alcott) moving towards a normal life, and Detective Claudia diverted by new cases, Dexter appeared free to sail away with a fresh list of victims.

For viewers craving more blood-soaked drama, the absence of a cliffhanger is unsettling.

The finale even showed Dexter embracing his Dark Passenger more fully than ever, breaking the fourth wall to remind audiences he is “exactly who you want me to be.”

With that chilling tease hanging in the air, fans are eager for more, but the question remains whether they will be granted with another season.

Is Dexter: Resurrection real?

Dexter: Resurrection marks the third revival of the iconic Showtime series and, unexpectedly, it proves the most satisfying since the Trinity Killer storyline. 

Set just weeks after New Blood, the drama sees Dexter Morgan (Michael C. Hall) wake from a coma in a New York hospital, having astonishingly survived being shot by his son, Harrison.

RELATED: 'Dexter: Resurrection' Season 2 - What we know so far