Tobey Maguire sparks controversy with new love interest

Tobey Maguire has been spotted with an influencer who is decades younger than him

By Aamna Razi February 11, 2026
Tobey Maguire sparks controversy with new love interest
Tobey Maguire sparks controversy with new love interest

Tobey Maguire’s latest love interest was spotted out with him at the Super Bowl LX on February 8th, and netizens have done their digging on the woman and figured out her identity.

The model is 20-year-old Mishka Silva, with the Spider-Man actor being 50, which has caused upheaval on social media.

In the images circulating of the duo online, they can be seen sitting in the VIP section at the massive sports event, busy in conversation.

Although the couple has not confirmed their relationship as of yet, the speculation surrounding it is already presuming that the two are a thing.

Tobey Maguire sparks controversy with new love interest

Internet users flocked to social media platforms such as X to denounce Tobey and to slam other actors or individuals that date much younger than their age.

“Do guys not feel weird when theyre dating someone around the same age as their own DAUGHTER?” one netizen wrote, referring to The Great Gatsby actor’s 19-year-old daughter Ruby Sweetheart Maguire.

Another added, “the girl being only a year older than his 19 year old daughter… someone actually needs to privately investigate tobey maguire with the way he always has an 18-22 year old girl by his side.”

A third internet user remarked, “she wasn’t even born when Spider-Man 2 came out man,” and a fourth commented “you turn 20 and your dating competition is dudes you looked up to when you were 5.”

Did Tobey Maguire date Kirsten Dunst?

Yes, Tobey and Kristen dated back in 2001 for a year, after which they split on good terms and continued playing love interests in upcoming films.

RELATED: Tobey Maguire back in dating game 10 years after divorce?